Reviewed by Daniel Murphy, EA, Founder of Murphy Accounting · Preparing Massachusetts tax returns since 2011 · Last reviewed
What the IRS has said
In a 27 June 2011 memo, “Booster Club Dues and Non-Exempt Activity,” the IRS Director of Exempt Organizations wrote that if a booster club confers a benefit on a participant in return for fundraising, such as crediting the amounts a participant raises toward that participant's dues or the cost of a trip, the club is providing a private benefit to that participant. Such practices “could result in the organization failing to be described in § 501(c)(3).”
The same memo warned that amounts credited to a participant's account for fundraising could be income from services, which can bring employment tax into the picture. It points to a 1993 IRS training text, “Athletic Booster Clubs: Are They Exempt?”, which covers the same ground.
What counts as an individual fundraising account
Booster networks call these individual fundraising accounts, or IFAs. Clubs rarely use that name for their own system, so look for the pattern instead. Any of these in your club's rules or spreadsheets is one:
- Each family has a running balance, and fundraising sales reduce what that family owes
- Wreath, candy or card sales where the seller's profit is applied to that student's trip
- “Fair share” rules where families who sell more pay less
- Students whose sales exceed their cost get a refund or a credit toward next year
- Sponsorships a parent secured are earmarked for that parent's child
Families usually set these up with good intentions. The problem is not the fundraising; it is tying the result to one participant's benefit.
Allowed or risky: common booster club practices
The line the IRS draws is between helping the program and paying back the person who raised the money. The table sorts the arrangements treasurers ask about most often.
| Practice | How it reads | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A family's sales reduce that family's dues or trip balance | Risky | The 2011 IRS memo calls this private benefit that could cost 501(c)(3) status |
| Points per dollar raised, applied to the family's own assessment | Risky | The system the Tax Court rejected in Capital Gymnastics |
| Sponsor money earmarked for one named athlete | Risky | Publication 526: a gift set aside for a specific person is not deductible, even through a charity |
| Required dues or trip fees receipted as donations | Risky for families | Fees buy something the family receives, so they are not gifts |
| All fundraising pooled to lower the cost for every participant | Generally fine | The benefit goes to the whole program, not to whoever sold the most |
| Need-based scholarships decided by a committee under written criteria | Generally fine | Help follows need, not fundraising results |
A small, incidental benefit to participants is normal: every athletic booster club helps individual athletes. The problem starts when the benefit to particular families is the point of the fundraising.
Are booster club donations tax deductible?
Only gifts to a qualified organization are deductible, so start by looking the club up in the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search. A club that is not recognized under section 501(c)(3), and is not operating as part of a public school or another qualified organization, cannot give donors a deduction at all.
The 2011 memo was prompted by an IRS Chief Counsel analysis of the families' side of the question. That analysis concluded that booster club participants may be able to deduct what they pay only to the extent it exceeds the value of the benefits they receive in return, and only if they intended the excess as a charitable contribution.
In practice, that means required fees for a trip, uniform or season are generally payments for something the family receives, not gifts. A separate, voluntary donation to the program is a gift. Keep the two apart in your records and on your receipts, so families are not told a fee is deductible when it is not.
One change matters from tax year 2026: people who take the standard deduction can deduct up to $1,000 of qualifying cash gifts to qualified charities, or $2,000 for married couples filing jointly (IRS IR-2026-135). That helps a family that gives voluntarily to a 501(c)(3) club. It does not turn a required fee into a gift.
- Required dues, trip costs and uniform fees: payments for benefits received
- Voluntary donations with nothing in return: contributions
- Payments over $75 that are partly a gift (a banquet ticket, for example): need a written quid pro quo disclosure
- Any single contribution of $250 or more: the donor needs a written acknowledgment
Receipts when fees and gifts are mixed
Do booster clubs have to give donors a receipt? Federal rules put the burden on the donor. For any single gift of $250 or more the donor needs a contemporaneous written acknowledgment, and IRS Publication 1771 says an organization that does not provide one incurs no penalty, although the donor then cannot deduct the gift. The exception is a payment over $75 that is partly for goods or services, such as a banquet ticket: the club must give a written disclosure, and the penalty for skipping it is $10 per contribution, up to $5,000 per event or mailing.
Our guide to whether a booster club needs 501(c)(3) status covers what an acknowledgment has to say. For clubs moving away from individual accounts, these are the points that trip treasurers up:
- Receipt required dues, trip costs and uniform fees as payments, never as donations
- If a family chooses to pay more than the required fee, only the extra can be acknowledged as a gift
- Never put a value on volunteer hours: Publication 526 says the value of time or services is not deductible
- Acknowledge sponsorships to the club, not to a named athlete
- Publication 1771 notes that charities typically send acknowledgments by January 31 of the following year
The Tax Court case treasurers should know
In Capital Gymnastics Booster Club, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2013-193, the Tax Court agreed with the IRS that a gymnastics booster club did not qualify under section 501(c)(3). Each family owed an annual assessment for competition costs. Families earned points for the profit their fundraising produced, including a scrip program that sold store gift cards, and the points reduced their own assessment. Families that did not fundraise paid in full.
The court held that the club had a substantial non-exempt purpose, serving the members who fundraised, and that its earnings inured to those members. It distinguished a school band selling candy for new uniforms, where the fundraising benefits the group as a whole.
The IRS still relies on the case. In a final determination released in August 2023 (IRS 202334016), it revoked a booster club's exemption because, like Capital Gymnastics, the club raised funds that benefited only the families who took part in the fundraisers. The letter told the club that contributions to it were no longer deductible and that it would generally have to file federal income tax returns and pay tax. It is a federal rule, so it applies the same way in Massachusetts.
A second, unrelated way to lose exemption is simpler: a club that does not file its required 990-series return, including the 990-N, for three consecutive years loses it automatically under section 6033(j). See automatic revocation and reinstatement and which return your club files.
Alternatives that keep the program fair
The goal most clubs are trying to reach, making sure no student is priced out, can be met without individual crediting.
- Pool all fundraising and use it to lower the cost for every participant equally
- Offer need-based scholarships decided by a committee under written criteria, without regard to how much a family raised
- Keep scholarship decisions confidential and document them in minutes
- Separate voluntary donations from required fees in your records and receipts
- Where a family pays a fee for a trip or uniform, treat that as a payment for something they receive, not a gift
Unwinding an existing system
- 1.Adopt a written board policy that fundraising proceeds benefit the program as a whole.
- 2.Announce the change before the next fundraising season, so families are not surprised mid-year.
- 3.Stop tracking fundraising results by family in any record that affects what a family owes.
- 4.Decide how to handle existing credit balances with advice from your tax preparer or an attorney, before anything is paid out.
- 5.Set up the scholarship committee and criteria before the first request comes in.
- 6.Tell whoever prepares your 990-series return what changed and when.
Where we come in
We can help you separate fees, donations and fundraising in the books, and prepare the club's returns once the policy is in place. Questions about legal exposure from past practices belong with an attorney. We give you a scope and a price in writing before anything starts.
Figures on this page were checked against the IRS and Massachusetts sources listed alongside on 20 Nov 2026. They change: confirm the current amount before relying on one.
General information for owner-led businesses, not advice for your specific situation. Tax and accounting rules change, and how they apply depends on facts particular to your business. Talk to us, or to another qualified professional, before acting on anything here.


